Nicholas Carriere outlines butler vs gardener AI agents

nicholascharriere.com6 min read

The author argues that AI agents are splitting into two distinct categories: 'butlers,' which serve individual users across their personal apps, and 'gardeners,' which maintain shared spaces like codebases or company knowledge bases. While butlers handle private, single-player knowledge work, they should not manage shared environments because uncoordinated updates lead to chaos. Instead, the author predicts the rise of intent-based agent-to-agent protocols where individual butlers submit changes for a central gardener agent to review and approve. Open article →